🔥 The Questions the Fire Never Answered
The Sodder Family Case, Reopened by Evidence
By Richie D. Mowrey for The Sassy Gazette
Dicking Around With Richie: A True Crime File
Christmas Eve, 1945. A family home burned to the ground in Fayetteville, West Virginia. Five children vanished. And the official explanation arrived faster than the evidence ever did.
For nearly eighty years, this case has been framed as a mystery.
It isn’t.
It’s a stack of unanswered questions that were never meant to be asked out loud.
Let’s ask them anyway.
📞 The Phone Lines
Cut, Not Burned
Why were the Sodder family phone lines cut?
This is not disputed. The line was found severed at the pole, fourteen feet above ground. Not melted. Not scorched. Cut.
Fire does not climb poles with wire cutters.
Someone disabled the Sodders’ ability to call for help before or during the fire. That single fact alone dismantles the idea of a random electrical accident.
If this was an accident, why did it require silencing?
🪜 The Ladder
Gone When It Was Needed Most
Where did the ladder go?
The Sodders kept a heavy extension ladder beside the house. It vanished the night of the fire. Days later, it was found dumped in a ditch roughly seventy-five feet away.
Ladders do not wander. Fires do not relocate equipment.
The ladder’s absence ensured one thing: no one could reach the attic windows where the children slept.
That is not coincidence. That is design.
🚚 The Trucks
Both Engines Failed. Both Worked Later.
Why would neither of George’s trucks start?
George Sodder tried to use his coal trucks as a makeshift platform to reach the attic. Neither would start. Both had worked earlier that day. Both worked again the next morning.
Two engines failing simultaneously in freezing weather is unlikely. Two engines failing at the exact moment rescue is needed is suspicious.
A neighbor later admitted to stealing a block and tackle from the Sodder garage that night. He also admitted to cutting the phone line, claiming he “thought it was a power line.”
That explanation asks us to believe incompetence aligned perfectly with tragedy.
I don’t.
💡 The Lights
Still On. Still Glowing.
If this was an electrical fire, why were the lights still on throughout the house?
This question has never been answered honestly.
If faulty wiring caused the fire, the circuit should have failed immediately. Yet multiple witnesses, including family members, reported the Christmas lights were still on as the house burned.
Electricity does not work that way.
Lights remaining on suggest the electrical system was intact, which means the fire likely started elsewhere.
Or was started.
🚒 The Fire Department
Seven Hours Late
Why did it take seven hours for the fire department to reach the Sodder home?
The fire began around 1:30 a.m. The fire department arrived at approximately 8:00 a.m.
Seven hours.
This wasn’t a remote mountain cabin. This was a family home on a state route. The explanation offered was a failed phone tree and a missing operator.
Which raises the next question.
☎️ The Operator
Absent When Needed
Why couldn’t anyone reach a phone operator? Where was the operator?
Multiple calls were attempted. None connected. Neighbors tried. Family members tried. No operator answered.
In a town of this size, on Christmas Eve, the complete collapse of communication is extraordinary.
Silence doesn’t happen by accident.
☎️ The Call
The Laugh That Didn’t Belong
What was the strange phone call Jennie Sodder received before the fire?
Just before midnight, Jennie received a call from a woman asking for an unfamiliar name. The caller laughed oddly. Glasses clinked in the background. It sounded like a party.
Wrong number, maybe. Or maybe reconnaissance.
Minutes later, something struck the roof. An hour later, the house was on fire.
That call has never been traced. Never explained. Never dismissed convincingly.
🦴 The Absence
What Fire Couldn’t Erase
Five children supposedly died in that house.
Yet:
- No bones were found
- No teeth
- No skull fragments
- No vertebrae
Even modern crematoriums leave remains.
A balloon-frame farmhouse cannot erase five bodies in under an hour. That is not speculation. That is proven fire science.
No remains means one thing.
They were not there.
🪧 The Family’s Response
People Who Know the Truth Don’t Rebuild
The Sodders never rebuilt their house. They bulldozed the site into a memorial garden.
They erected a billboard with their children’s faces and a question that haunted the road for decades:
WHAT WAS THEIR FATE?
People who accept accidents move on. People who know something was taken do not.
🕯️ What These Questions Tell Us
Each question alone is troubling. Together, they form a pattern that refuses to be ignored.
- Communication disabled
- Rescue tools removed
- Vehicles sabotaged
- Lights contradicting cause
- Emergency response delayed
- Official explanations rushed
- Evidence falsified
- Science ignored
That is not tragedy. That is failure layered on top of intent.
⚖️ The Only Honest Conclusion
The Sodder case is not unsolved because it is unknowable.
It is unsolved because the answers were inconvenient.
Five children vanished. A family refused to accept a lie. And a system chose closure over truth.
These questions remain because they were never meant to be answered.
Until someone finally does.
🕯️ A Note to the Reader
If you’ve made it this far, you already know this case isn’t about mystery for mystery’s sake.
It’s about whether we accept explanations that violate physics, biology, and common sense simply because they were stamped “official.”
It’s about whether silence counts as closure.
Smart people don’t dismiss evidence because it’s uncomfortable. Smart people don’t confuse repetition with truth. And smart people don’t accept impossibilities when science says otherwise.
Five children vanished. Their parents never stopped asking why. And nearly eighty years later, neither should we.
If the children died in that house, their remains should exist. They don’t.
That isn’t a belief. That’s a fact.
So the next time someone calls the Sodder case a “tragic accident,” ask them the same questions George and Jennie Sodder asked for the rest of their lives.
Then wait.
Because the silence that follows is the real story.
Comments
Post a Comment